Has NATO Been Nothing But Trouble For Ukraine?

Tim Black, Spiked: NATO has been nothing but trouble for Ukraine

For decades, it has been goading Russia into a conflict it never intended to fight.

At the Vilnius summit this week, NATO leaders have been telling anyone who will listen that Ukraine’s future lies within NATO. As US president Joe Biden put it to Ukrainian president Volodymyr Zelensky, Ukraine is going to become a NATO member.

But these are hollow words. NATO’s torturous communiqué, published on Tuesday, drowned any promise of membership in a sea of caveats. NATO leaders will ‘extend an invitation’ to Ukraine to join NATO after the war ends.

But only if ‘allies agree and conditions are met’; only if they’re satisfied with ‘Ukraine’s progress on interoperability’; and only if Ukraine undertakes ‘democratic and security-sector reforms’. NATO has extended an invitation with one hand and withdrawn it with the other.

Read more ....

WNU Editor: NATO has not been helpful. But truth be told, they are not the primary reason why Ukraine is in the disastrous mess that it is in right now.

Relations between Ukrainians and Russian-Ukrainians have a long history of hostility that came to a head during the Maidan Revolution when Ukrainian nationalists were successful in overthrowing a democratically led government that was pro-Russian. NATO and the West may have applauded the outcome and give moral encouragement, but they were not the instrument to make it happen.

After 2014 there has been a number of opportunities to end the conflict. The Minsk accord was one of them, an accord that Zelensky himself ran on in the last Presidential election promising that he would sign. He did not. Instead seeking a military solution that this blog since 2014 has been warning about would lead to a never-ending war.

I know it is easy to blame others for mistakes and bad outcomes. This past weekend Foreign Policy had an article blaming Obama's Russian Doctrine for preparing the ground work for this war. But in the end it was the leadership in Kyiv that had the power to influence events for a peaceful outcome. They choose not to, miscalculating what Russia would do, and the consequences of their actions.

from War News Updates https://ift.tt/JoX0GyH
via IFTTT

Comments

US And Russian Chiefs Of Staff Discuss Ukraine In Rare Phone Call

U.S. Chairman of the Joint Chiefs of Staff Gen. Mark Milley (left) and his Russian counterpart Valery Gerasimov (file photo) The Hill: Milley speaks with Russian counterpart for first time since start of war Chairman of the Joint Chiefs of Staff Gen. Mark Milley spoke with his Russian counterpart on Thursday, the first such conversation between the two since the Kremlin’s invasion of Ukraine began in late February, according to the Pentagon. Milley spoke by phone with Valery Gerasimov, chief of the Russian general staff, and they “discussed several security-related issues of concern and agreed to keep the lines of communication open,” Joint Staff spokesperson Col. Dave Butler said in a readout of the conversation. The Pentagon did not provide further information on the conversation. Read more .... WNU Editor: So much for the reports last week that Chief of the General Staff of the Armed Forces of Russia Valery Gerasimov was fired b...

Is Putin's Inner Circle Already In Discussions On Who Is Going To Replace Him?

Russian President Vladimir Putin leads a meeting on economic issues in Moscow on Monday. (Alexei Nikolsky, Sputnik, Kremlin Pool Photo via AP) Daily Beast: Putin’s Own Men Are Already Discussing Who Will Replace Him Three months into Vladimir Putin’s bloody “special operation” in Ukraine, his own men in the Kremlin are reportedly discussing who will replace him. That’s according to new reporting by the independent news outlet Meduza, which cited several sources close to the Russian presidential administration who said officials are increasingly fed up with Putin personally. Some of Putin’s own allies within the Kremlin walls have reportedly floated the idea of Moscow Mayor Sergei Sobyanin becoming his successor, or former President Dmitry Medvedev, who is now the deputy chairman of the Security Council. Sergei Kirienko, the first deputy chief of staff of the presidential administration, was also said to have been discussed as a contender. Read mor...

China's shipyard CSSC launches 1st Pakistani Hangor class submarine PNS Hangor

According to information published by the Pakistani MoD on April 26, 2024, the Hangor class submarine PNS Hangor was launched by the Chinese shipyard CSSC. This submarine is a part of the Hangor-class, which itself is based on the Yuan-class Type 039B submarines provided by China. Read full news at this link Hangor class submarine PNS Hangor. (Picture source: Pakistani MoD) Read more from World Defence News https://ift.tt/dgQWhs7 via IFTTT

MTQ News

Search This Blog